As of late, Pakistan’s been in a bad way. U.S. and C.I.A. plans to moderate Musharraf’s madness and build his legitimacy through cooperation with opposition leader Benazir Bhutto have completely collapsed: post-martial law, post-house arrest, Musharraf has emerged as the oppressor, Bhutto as the freedom fighter, Musharraf marshaling thousands of police against protest and Bhutto in eminent danger of assassination. U.S. fumbling and incompetence has made a complete clusterfuck out of a crisis.

The U.S. needs to immediately stop supporting General Musharraf. After all, what was the rational for aiding Musharraf’s government?
- he’s America’s ally in anti-terrorism.
- he’s promised a “path to democracy” for Pakistan with fair elections, free press, the works
Now he’s neither. As of November 3, 2007, he’s certainly no path to democracy I’ve ever seen: declaring martial law and suspending the supreme court to protect his presidency, removing dissenting judges, censoring the media, arresting over 3,500 lawyers, civil rights leaders, and liberal politicians, banning public protest, and suspending the Constitution are all decidedly un-democratic moves. Musharraf’s been smart enough to frame his dictatorship as an anti-terrorist move:
In the last few months, our situation has changed dramatically. Terrorism and Extremism are rampant. Suicide bombings are widespread. In Karachi, Rawalpindi, Sargodha, fanatacism is now common. Fundamentalist extemists are everywhere. They are not afraid of law-enforcement agencies.
(Musharraf’s address to the nation)
Yet, U.S. support continues because Musharraf still represents security in Pakistan and thus that corner of the Muslim World… except he doesn’t. First of all, the U.S. is undermining its own credibility (as usual) by publicly supporting an obvious dictator just because of empty sweet talking. This subsequently creates yet more completely legitimate reasons to hate the U.S. Second, the people of Pakistan, more than ever, now have [even more] legitimate reason to rebel against their government—Musharraf argued that he imposed martial law to stabilize Pakistan, but ironically he’s done just the opposite. So, in effect Musharraf is fanning the complex flames of terrorism in his own interest—and America’s paying him to do it. Meanwhile, the possibility for safe, free elections and the establishment of a moderate government with a true mandate to fight terrorism is quickly fading.
The bigger picture is that America needs to stop supporting dictators under the mistaken impression that it can somehow control them. That’s complete fiction, as has been proved time and time again in Iraq (Saddam Hussein), Chile (General Pinochet), Argentina (General Videla), Indonesia (Suharto), Iran (The Shah), Zaire (Mobutu), Cuba (Batista), Haiti (Papa & Baby Doc), and so on. America’s arrogance consistently undermines both its own best interest and the self-determination of people in non-Western countries.
Recent Comments